Article

Justin Bell
Justin Bell 15 April 2016

March Madness - A Perfect Analogy for Agile vs. Waterfall Methodology

Each year millions of Americans fill out NCAA March Madness brackets trying to pick as many games correctly as possible. I use this analogy to explain the differences between waterfall and Agile and highlight the benefits of Agile for product development.

March Madness is one of my favorite sports "seasons" each year.  The NCAA basketball tournament contains a combination of powerhouses from major conferences, but also the Cinderella stories of small school teams from small conferences who get their chance to compete.  

Many fans (even those that don't watch basketball all year long) participate in "bracket challenges" to see who can pick the winners of the tournament games.  

The reason this is so much fun is that it is unpredictable.  Generally the higher seeds win, but without fail, every year, there are some exciting, completed unpredictable results.  This year, who expected Yale to beat Baylor or Stephen F. Austin to beat West Virginia?

GetFile-(17).jpg

I use this as an analogy for the differences between Agile and traditional (waterfall) methodologies for software development / technology projects.

The quick version of it is that in a March Madness bracket challenge you have to use a Waterfall approach to picking the games.  

  • You do all of the "analysis" up front, looking at match ups of different teams, strength of schedules, individual player match ups, etc.
  • You pick all of the future outcomes (multiple rounds into the future)
  • You then lock in that "plan" and play all of the games

Your bracket (just like your requirements or project plan in Waterfall) aren't setup to respond well to changes.  After the first round of games, we now know that Baylor is not going to be in the Final Four, so all of the time and effort spent analyzing the matchup between Baylor and Oklahoma in the Elite Eight was waisted effort and the picks are now surely wrong.

An Agile approach would allow you to do all of that analysis on the first round of games only, with only some light "roadmapping" of the rest of the games.  You'd then watch the first round of games (do the 1st sprint) and adapt your plan.  You'd then do that detailed analysis on the 2nd round of games, based on the actual results of the first games.  You still wouldn't pick every game correctly, but you would ultimately get a lot more of the games correct and spend a lot less time analyzing things that are never going to happen.

My friend and colleague Austin Walker put this theory to the test the last couple of years and wrote about the outcomes.  You can read his series here:

About: Justin Bell is a Vice President at Credera. He enjoys leading teams and working with clients on their digital strategy, understanding how technology can be used to accomplish business objectives and IT Velocity/Efficiency initiatives.  

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

What's the difference between digital marketing and traditional marketing, and why does it matter? The answers may surprise you.

Julie Cave
Julie Cave 14 July 2016
Read more
12 Online Editing and Proofreading Tools Content Writers Should Know About

12 Online Editing and Proofreading Tools Content Writers Should Know About

If you've got great ideas to share, but your content is riddled with errors, you could lose the trust of your readers and your credibility. Get through this editing process quickly and painlessly, by enlisting the help of some online editing and proofreading tools, so you can get your error-free content out there and read.

Gloria Kopp
Gloria Kopp 22 March 2017
Read more
How To Create Landing Pages That Convert

How To Create Landing Pages That Convert

Effective landing pages are often standalone web pages written with one specific goal in mind. This goal is usually conversions or getting readers to take a certain action. Knowing what action you want readers to take is helpful for turning them into customers. This article will explain the six essentials of creating a landing page that converts.

Eric Gordon
Eric Gordon 20 March 2017
Read more
4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

It goes without saying that a company can't do without digital marketing in today's world.

Digital Doughnut Contributor
Digital Doughnut Contributor 5 November 2014
Read more
[Infographic] Why Email Is At The Heart Of Marketing Automation

[Infographic] Why Email Is At The Heart Of Marketing Automation

This infographic, based on Part 1 of our new report, looks at the role of email at the heart of marketing automation.

Natasha Farrell
Natasha Farrell 21 March 2017
Read more