Article

Caroline Oliver
Caroline Oliver 8 May 2013
Categories Search Marketing

Google Knowledge Graph: Answers Not Pages

In May 2012, Google announced a new feature to its search product: a knowledge base that would contain verified informat

In May 2012, Google announced a new feature to its search product: a knowledge base that would contain verified information that could answer search queries directly. They called it Knowledge Graph.

The logic was sound. When people search for Benedict Cumberbatch, they most likely aren’t looking for a page about the Sherlock Holmes star- they’re just looking for information about him. The movies he’s acted in, that show you saw him in last night and if Alan Rickman really is his dad. 

 

By providing users with that relevant information immediately, Google could tap into the value offered by answer engines of old, like Ask Jeeves, or more pertinently, that friend of yours who always seems to know way too much about celebrities.

But how relevant is the information turning up in Knowledge Graph?

While bigger stars like Cumberbatch have accurate information about them in their knowledge graph entries, some of the comparatively smaller stars who’ve earned knowledge graph entries still have to contend with occasional moments of misinformation.

World renowned drummer Gary Husband for instance, has a vast list of Level 42 songs attributed to him in spite of the fact that he wasn’t involved in writing, producing or even performing most of them during his tenure with the band. For an independent, far-reaching and original artist like him, this somewhat major miscalculation of his temporary relationship with Level 42 could have a big impact.
 
He explains: “Google’s Knowledge Graph is gravely misrepresenting a large number of artists that I know, myself included, by frequently presenting misinformation as "factual" information (more akin to Wikipedia).  Since Google is widely perceived as a trusted source of intelligence, such widespread errors have the potential to be highly damaging to artists’ careers and of course wholly misleading to anyone searching for accurate facts - journalists, booking agents, producers, promoters or fans. But for me, the most alarming part of all this is that we seem powerless in our efforts to get Google to rectify the errors.  This is totally unacceptable. The lengths I have gone to over the past nine months to set my own ’record’ straight with Google have been in vain: it would seem that nobody there is remotely interested.” 

So where exactly is Google getting the entry wrong? It would appear they’re misunderstanding some of the information they’re collecting and the quality of relationships between them.
 
All the data in knowledge graph comes from four sources: Wikipedia, Freebase, The CIA World Factbook andinterestingly enough for brands, Google Plus. All 570 million objects, 18 Billion facts and the relationships between all these different entries are based on the information available in these four sources.

The algorithms traversing this massive amount of data appear to occasionally misinterpret the quality of some of this information. In the case of Husband, it might be Wikipedia’s separated section about his relationship with Level 42 being misconstrued for greater involvement.

Where the algorithms are misfiring, is something that will only ever be clear to Google.

What is clear though, is that Google are aware their algorithms aren’t perfect just yet. Hence their repeated removal and re-entry of different Knowledge Graph sections from time to time.
With some interesting competition from Bing’s knowledge base Satori, Google are certainly being kept on their toes when it comes to making sure their knowledge graph entries are always relevant and useful.

More importantly, if Google are to keep up the incredible momentum they’ve worked up in their march towards semantically indexed, socially relevant search results, then they’ll be desperately keen to make sure the entries for Husband are as accurate as the entries for Cumberbatch.

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
The Impact of New Technology on Marketing

The Impact of New Technology on Marketing

Technology has impacted every part of our lives. From household chores to business disciplines and etiquette, there's a gadget or app for it. Marketing has changed dramatically over the years, but what is the...

Alex Lysak
Alex Lysak 22 September 2020
Read more
It’s Time For Brands to Move From Personalised, to Personal

It’s Time For Brands to Move From Personalised, to Personal

At a time when almost every brand is tailoring content and offers to individual customers based on their demographic data, purchase history, and online behaviours, are these personalisation efforts still adding value?...

Shafqat Islam
Shafqat Islam 27 November 2023
Read more
The Carrot of a Bigger Market is More Powerful Than the Stick of Legal Action in Driving Web Accessibility Investment, New Research Finds

The Carrot of a Bigger Market is More Powerful Than the Stick of Legal Action in Driving Web Accessibility Investment, New Research Finds

Getting web accessibility right is a massive commercial opportunity. The World Health Organization estimates that 1.3bn people worldwide are living with some form of impairment. The benefits of making it easier for...

Michael Nutley
Michael Nutley 30 November 2023
Read more
The 3 Most Important Stages In Your Presentation

The 3 Most Important Stages In Your Presentation

If you want to deliver a presentation on a particular topic and you have to prepare yourself for it you should make sure that you go through several very important stages in order to craft a compelling, persuasive and...

Nicky Nikolaev
Nicky Nikolaev 16 February 2016
Read more
From Success to Setback: Lessons in MarTech Decision-Making

From Success to Setback: Lessons in MarTech Decision-Making

We often talk to clients about the consolidation of MarTech capabilities across vendors, to the point that it’s often not too difficult to pick up a new technology if you’re comfortable working with an alternative...

Andrew Addison
Andrew Addison 29 November 2023
Read more