Matt Althauser
Matt Althauser 4 December 2013
Categories Data & Analytics

Testing the strength of the paywall

Paywalls and page views - the challenge for digital marketers

Testing the strength of the paywall

By Matt Althauser, European General Manager, Optimizely


In 2010, The Times caused huge controversy when it moved its online content behind a paywall, a ‘crazy move’ even according to Mike Darcey, the man who would become CEO of News UK. However, we have since seen a shift in approach, with four national UK publications now operating a paywall system; The Sun and The Telegraph having introduced their schemes over recent months. While it is unsurprising that publishers are looking to monetise online content, paywalls introduce a new set of challenges for their sales and marketing teams.


Consumers have been willing to pay for traditional print magazines and newspapers, but online versions have long been taken for granted as a free service. Recent research reveals the extent of the problem. 80 per cent of UK internet users polled in August 2013 stated that newspaper paywalls were either a ‘bad idea as they would not pay for online news content’ or ‘pointless because the same stories were available for free elsewhere’. This is evidenced by their behavior when a paywall is introduced; it was reported that The Sun’s web traffic dropped by 60 per cent after the introduction of its paywall.


This reluctance to pay for web-based content presents publishers with issues when it comes to monetising online editions.


Paywalls and page views – the challenge for digital marketers

While driving online subscriptions is a key concern for sales teams, digital marketers are also affected by the introduction of paywalls. Marketers in the publishing industry are focused on increasing page consumption. Their remit is to boost engagement through Facebook recommendations, LinkedIn shares and tweets to drive page views. The more places a link to the article exists, the more eyeballs will land on it - increasing ad impressions.


However, it is difficult to increase online engagement if readers are being blocked from the very pages marketers want them to consume.  Therefore, publishers need to consider paywall strategy from both a sales and a marketing perspective, considering how digital marketers can keep readers engaged through the paywall as well as developing strategies to increase online subscriptions.


Not all paywalls are built alike

It is important to note that no two paywalls are created equal. A ‘hard’ wall blocks visitors from reading any article until they subscribe, whereas a ‘soft’ wall makes select content viewable before a subscription is required. The Financial Times recently introduced a system whereby non-subscribers can elect to answer survey questions, providing market insights in return for reading articles. But how many UK newspapers are actually testing their paywalls?


The key to developing a successful paywall strategy lies in online testing, to learn more about what readers are willing to do or pay to access content. Important questions include how permeable a paywall should be and how much, if any, content should be available prior to hitting a paywall.  Optimal solutions will not be developed through intuition or assumption. For publishers to be profitable online they need to apply rigorous, scientific and focused testing strategies and put in place insight based solutions.


A/B testing: How can publishers optimise their paywalls?
A/B testing platforms, like those provided by Optimizely, are used to investigate the impact of adjustments to a website, allowing web developers to test how design, layout and messaging impact customer behaviour. Testing is an essential tool to help publications develop a paywall strategy that will work for their readership.


The paywall page is the perfect starting point for publishers looking to implement a testing strategy. The goal on this page is for a reader to click on the call to action to subscribe. This creates multiple testing opportunities, from simple changes like the size and font of the call-to-action, to less obvious things like the language used for the ‘subscribe button’ (for example ‘try it now’ versus ‘get the full story’).


The majority of tests could be set up in minutes and answer critical questions about how the paywall should be presented to maximise subscriptions. After the publication answers some of these basic, but critical, questions it can get more sophisticated by using segmentation to push different content to distinct user groups. Segmentation strategies to consider include:

  • Mobile device versus desktop : It is possible to show tablet users a promotional image that conveys reading news on the go, while desktop users see an image of a user reading the paper at home on the computer
  • Recent visitors: Publications can also welcome recent readers back to the site, before offering them special promotions to sign up
  • Multiple blocked: If a reader has attempted to read a number of articles behind a paywall, publications can target them with messages to emphasise what they are missing by not signing up
  • Category specific: Readers who view science articles might be inspired by a promotion that promotes the best, science related content behind the paywall

There is no doubt that the game has changed for publishers and it is too soon to tell which type of paywall model, if any, will prevail. While the received wisdom is that paywalls are disliked by readers, through testing it is possible to see how readers respond best to these changes – as well as driving subscription. However some publications such as The Times and The New York Times have already managed to roll out profitable paywall schemes, demonstrating it is possible to monetise online content.


As print media continues to decline, the publishers that survive will be those who are willing to experiment with their online presence to make decisions based on test-based insight before innovating rapidly to ensure they are driving sales and enabling marketing strategies that work in a world where paywalls are a reality.

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

What's the difference between digital marketing and traditional marketing, and why does it matter? The answers may surprise you.

Julie Cave
Julie Cave 14 July 2016
Read more
4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

It goes without saying that a company can't do without digital marketing in today's world.

Digital Doughnut Contributor
Digital Doughnut Contributor 5 November 2014
Read more
How To Create Landing Pages That Convert

How To Create Landing Pages That Convert

Effective landing pages are often standalone web pages written with one specific goal in mind. This goal is usually conversions or getting readers to take a certain action. Knowing what action you want readers to take is helpful for turning them into customers. This article will explain the six essentials of creating a landing page that converts.

Eric Gordon
Eric Gordon 20 March 2017
Read more
12 Online Editing and Proofreading Tools Content Writers Should Know About

12 Online Editing and Proofreading Tools Content Writers Should Know About

If you've got great ideas to share, but your content is riddled with errors, you could lose the trust of your readers and your credibility. Get through this editing process quickly and painlessly, by enlisting the help of some online editing and proofreading tools, so you can get your error-free content out there and read.

Gloria Kopp
Gloria Kopp 22 March 2017
Read more
7 Advanced Ways to Reduce Email Churn Rates

7 Advanced Ways to Reduce Email Churn Rates

While you can’t always prevent readers from opting out of your emails, you can reduce the likelihood of them doing so with a few proven practices. In this article I’m going to show what many influencers do to reduce email churn and nurture a better relationship with their audience, and how you can too.

Kristian Jønsson
Kristian Jønsson 16 March 2017
Read more