Article

Aniel Bhaga
Aniel Bhaga 12 December 2017

Why you shouldn’t use Multiple ESPs (Email Service Providers)

Using multiple Email Service Providers might seem like a good idea for your business. Trying out various free plans and trying to get by without paying as much. Or it could be one department likes using one provider and another department likes a different one. Whatever the reason you it is doing a lot more damage to your marketing and business efforts than you realise...

It may seem like a great idea to use multiple email service providers all together such as Ungapped, MailChimp & SendGrid for various business activities.  You may even feel that it is improving your business processes or it poses no issues at all. In the short term if you are testing out various systems it won’t, outside this it will.

At Ungapped we believe that you should not use multiple ESPs. If you do want to change to another ESP then change everything together. We have our top 5 reasons and will share them with you below. Along with this I have found some excerpts from interviews with other experts in the field and what they have to say. Overall we come to the same conclusion that using more than one ESP is not a helpful at all.

Why you should stick with one ESP

  1. You will can a complete view of what your customers are interacting with and how engaged they are with your emails.
  2. Managing subscribes and unsubscribes is simpler, you don’t have to cross check and update various systems.
  3. You have a holistic view of what emails are being sent out and to who so not un-intentionally overwhelm your customers.
  4. Your sending reputation will grow, as you are sending from one ESP you reduce the risk of being seen as a spammer.
  5. Using one platform enables you to see what emails are performing better or worse, with open rates, bounces, clicks. Enabling you to iterate fast and update each communication.

What other experts have to say:

“I’d not recommend it unless you are a global organization where there is no centralized control and in region requirements that differ dramatically. You are minimizing the value of engagement by separating transactional from triggers and promotional/batch. You also lose the aggregate value of ‘seeing’ what’s happening across your customer base, market and people that may be in different markets but exhibit like-behaviors. It’s just as hard to manage at scale without a mission and the mission shouldn’t be to Band-Aid your existing ESP, as you’ll get fractional value from each. I would only use multiple vendors if you plan to switch to help ease the transition, or you are so big you aren’t centralized to reap the benefits.”
– David Baker, Cofounder and Chief Strategy & Operations Officer, Cordial

“My advice would be to avoid messaging sprawl. Messaging sprawl can lead to a dangerous over messaging of clients. Let me give you an example: the marketing team uses one ESP, the partner and loyalty team uses another, a third is used by customer service, and legal/compliance uses some in-house tool. It’s nearly impossible to know when or how often one of these groups sends a communication. The likelihood that someone could hear from all four groups in the course of a single day can be quite high. Additionally, there is the question of efficacy: how do you analyze performance and understand the impact of all that messaging? You wind up burdening yourself with building a BI system, getting all the data into it to analyze, synching things like bounces, suppression lists etc. across platforms. You see where I’m going with this? Choosing the right ESP is important, it’s your bridge, a conduit, a critical line of communication to your customers and it is highly measurable and should feed your understanding of your company’s performance.”
– Len Shneyder, VP of Industry Relations, SendGrid

“Using multiple ESPs is like a frequent traveler staying in multiple hotel chains: most don’t do enough volume to build reputation across both. If you’re spreading yourself across multiple ESPs, odds are you will not only lack the volume per IP to build reputation with the internet service providers (ISPs), you’ll also put yourself at risk of being identified as a snowshoe spammer.”
– Mike Hillyer, Director of Product Marketing, SparkPost

“Using multiples ESPs is no replacement for a proactive, well thought out deliverability sending strategy. However, there are use cases where sending from more than one ESP fits into a company’s business goals. For example, if your company has both B2B and B2C divisions, this could warrant using different ESPs to cater to each market. Keep in mind that there are higher costs associated with using multiple ESPs. Splitting your volume across ESPs will usually increase your CPM costs since CPM rates typically drop with higher sending volumes. There are also labor costs associated with learning and training staff on a second ESP platform. These labor costs can be easily overlooked, but could become significant over time.”
– Dan Deneweth, Senior Director, Strategic Services (Deliverability), Oracle Marketing Cloud

“Not as a long term solution. If you’re evaluating or testing various solutions out (running a proof of concept, for example), that’s one thing. Some senders will also send transactional, triggered, and marketing mailings from different ESPs, but that can get messy. Ideally, one ESP handles it all.”
– Roger Barnette, CEO, MessageGears

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

What's the difference between digital marketing and traditional marketing, and why does it matter? The answers may surprise you.

Julie Cave
Julie Cave 14 July 2016
Read more
7 reasons why social media marketing is important for your business

7 reasons why social media marketing is important for your business

Social media is quickly becoming one of the most important aspects of digital marketing, which provides incredible benefits that help reach millions of customers worldwide. And if you are not applying this profitable...

Sharron Nelson
Sharron Nelson 6 February 2018
Read more
Top 10 B2B Platforms to Help your Business Grow Worldwide

Top 10 B2B Platforms to Help your Business Grow Worldwide

Although the trend of a Business to Business portal is not new but the evolution of technology has indeed changed the way they function. Additional digital trading features and branding has taken the place of...

Salman Sharif
Salman Sharif 7 July 2017
Read more
Collection Of The Best Email Testing Tools Online

Collection Of The Best Email Testing Tools Online

Don’t be afraid of email testing. There are many free or freemium tools online that can help you with testing your SPAM score, deliverability and even the rendering of your email. We feature 30 email testing tools in...

Roland Pokornyik
Roland Pokornyik 31 October 2016
Read more
Three Major Google Algorithm Updates That Changed SEO - Are You Compliant?

Three Major Google Algorithm Updates That Changed SEO - Are You Compliant?

Search Engine Optimisation has become so much more than fitting keywords into the page and fine-tuning your meta data. In recent years, Google has introduced a series of algorithms that take machine learning to new...

Matt Cayless
Matt Cayless 7 August 2018
Read more