Article

Derek Slater
Derek Slater 7 April 2016
Categories B2B, Content

How to Ruin Your Content Marketing (One Review at a Time)

Traditional marketing reviews can chip away at reader value. Watch it happen in slow motion—so you can learn to prevent it.

Photo:  Nasa Goddard Space Flight Center, Licensed via CC 2.0

The first rule of good content marketing is to put the audience first. People are pretty sophisticated; they can differentiate something intended to help or entertain them from something that’s just advertising in disguise. 

That doesn’t mean good content can’t advance key messages. It should. But it can’t sacrifice connecting with the audience.

Most marketers and business executives get this concept. But often, when they’re asked to review a piece of content marketing, they are inclined to make changes that prioritize their own agendas over strengthening its connective tissue, often in ways that, when you take a big step back, don’t advance that agenda much.

Here’s a fictional example: an article about an enterprise technology implementation at MegaCorp, written by well-intentioned software maker Tyrell. The target audience is CIOs.

Here’s a snippet of the draft copy

...But the eight-member Technical Committee’s proposed solution was subject to vigorous debate.

“We fought like cats and dogs, honestly,” laughs MegaCorp’s CIO. “The finance guys were focused on performance, because they want to do their jobs faster, but ultimately we realized that API features mattered more than a 10 percent performance boost.”

1st review: edits by the source, MegaCorp’s CIO

...But the eight-member Technical Committee’s proposed solution was subject to vigorous debate.

We fought like cats and dogs, honestly, It took careful review to arrive at consensus,” laughs said MegaCorp’s CIO. “The finance guys were focused on performance, because they want to do their jobs faster, but ultimately we realized that API features mattered more than a 10 percent performance boost.”

2nd review: edits by MegaCorp’s legal/compliance team

...But the eight-member Technical committee’s proposed solution was subject to vigorous debate thorough evaluation.

It took After careful review we arrived at consensus” said MegaCorp’s CIO. “The finance guys were focused on performance, because they want to do their jobs faster ensuring 100 percent adherence to regulatory requirements, but ultimately we realized that API features mattered more than a 10 percent performance boost we could also have robust API features.”

3rd review: edits by MegaCorp’s PR/comms team

...But the committee’s proposed solution was subject to thorough evaluation. All products used at MegaCorp are subject to a rigorous safety review.

“After careful review we arrived at consensus” said MegaCorp’s CIO. “The finance guys were department was focused on ensuring 100 percent adherence to regulatory requirements, and our customers come first in everything we do at MegaCorp. but ultimately we realized we could also have robust API features. 

4th review: final edits by Tyrell’s marketing team

All products used at MegaCorp are subject to a rigorous safety review.

“After careful consideration we arrived at consensus, made the obvious choice, Tyrell™,” said MegaCorp’s CIO. “The finance department was focused on ensuring 100 percent adherence to regulatory requirements.” Tyrell™ is No. 1 in the industry because of its awesome Widgetifier© technology. It’s a great match “because customers come first in everything we do at MegaCorp.”

How’d we do?

All reviews completed! Final copy is ready for publication!

And what do you suppose the intended audience will think when they read it?

Probably something like: If we did a project like that, even if it had any measurable payoff, it would have to go through our technical committee and our finance guys, and we’d fight like cats and dogs.

 Then they’ll click away, with no connection made.

The reviewers gradually removed any hint of conflict, all technical detail, all ROI or performance metrics—any of the real-world issues that any real potential Tyrell customer will have to think about and prepare for. The first version had value because it was candid. The final version has none.

So what do all these revisions have in common? They're all focused on making someone other than the reader look good.

Instead, focus your content marketing—and your review process—on the reader. Good things will follow.

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

What's the difference between digital marketing and traditional marketing, and why does it matter? The answers may surprise you.

Julie Cave
Julie Cave 14 July 2016
Read more
4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

It goes without saying that a company can't do without digital marketing in today's world.

Digital Doughnut Contributor
Digital Doughnut Contributor 5 November 2014
Read more
Instagram Contests – How to a run an excellent and legal contest

Instagram Contests – How to a run an excellent and legal contest

Running Instagram contests is a great idea! Instagram is a huge social media platform, with 700 million monthly active users. So just being active on it already significantly increases your reach and social media presence. But running contest can take it to the next level by increasing your engagement, generating leads, and making your audience happy.

Jan Zajac
Jan Zajac 15 August 2017
Read more
What is a CMS?

What is a CMS?

You’ve heard the term CMS, but what is it, what does it actually do? A CMS empowers you to get your companies' message out there, internally, externally or both.

Sean Hargrave
Sean Hargrave 14 August 2017
Read more
Twitter: The Complaint Box?

Twitter: The Complaint Box?

Twitter has proved to be a vastly versatile platform over the years – but has the facilitated interaction between brands and customers turned it into a complaint box?

Teodora Miscov
Teodora Miscov 18 August 2017
Read more