How to Spot Fake Reviews - 4 Warning Signs

Discover how to spot the fakes so you can protect the legitimate ones and increase conversions.

Nearly four out of five people consult online ratings and reviews – discover how to spot the fakes so you can protect the legitimate ones and increase conversions.



You might want to sit down before reading this, but this is something you need to know. The most trusted form of marketing isn’t your glossy brochure, expensive website or helpful YouTube videos. In fact, it’s not any form of marketing you’ve created at all. It’s the ratings and reviews of customers that are the most powerful in persuading consumers to buy.


This was the finding of Nielsen’s Global Trust in Advertising report and, as you’d expect, we tend to agree. The power of word of mouth was backed up by our own survey of 2,000 UK consumers, in which we discovered that:

  • 77% consult online ratings and reviews before buying.
  • Nearly two-thirds are more likely to buy based on a positive rating or review.
  • One out of five will spend more with a retailer that has good ratings and reviews.

With the help of maths wizard (or mathemagician) William Hartson, from Cambridge University, we calculated that positive ratings and reviews can boost revenue by as much as 40% a year, as a result of reduced shopping cart abandonment and higher trust. Being the clever people they are, Harvard Business School arrived at a similar conclusion. They assessed that a single star rating increase can boost restaurant bookings by nearly 10%.


Clamping Down on Fake Reviews

The massive influence ordinary people have on buying decisions has, inevitably, led crafty types to try to abuse the system for personal gain.

Gartner predicted in 2012 that up to 15% of online ratings and reviews could be fake by this year. A shocking statistic, but thankfully the fight against fake reviews is well underway.


While authorities are starting to take action, they’re going to need some help. Fake ratings and reviews harm the validity, trustworthiness and power of legitimate feedback. Ratings and review communities need to be empowered to spot fake reviews and get them removed. Thankfully there are common tell-tale signs that a rating or review might not be kosher.



4 Warning Signs of Fake Reviews

Once again, academia has come to the rescue with Cornell University stepping in to identify the warnings signs of fake reviews:


Excessive use of ‘I’
In a misguided attempt to appear like a real person, fake reviewers will refer to themselves in the first person more than a genuine person.


Over the top
An obvious red flag is when a reviewer talks about vacuum cleaners as the dawning of a new age in carpet hygiene. When reviews are over the top and emotional, with excessive superlatives, exaggeration and exclamation points, they give the whiff of someone trying too hard to convince others of something they don’t really believe themselves.


Keyword stuffing
Like mischievous gremlins, the same keywords will crop up in reviews posted by a fake reviewer in various corners of the web. For hotel reviews this includes ‘nice’, ‘deal’, ‘comfort’ and ‘stay’. They may get jumbled up, but a fake review’s keywords come from the same song sheet.


Extreme positivity or negativity
It’s natural for people to be enthusiastic after a good shopping experience, but fake reviews take this to the extreme. If someone says something is the ‘best ever’ or the ‘absolute worst’ without getting into specifics, something may be amiss.


Weed Out the Fakes so Your Real Reviews can Flourish

As all the studies mentioned have proven:

  • Cultivating ratings and reviews is the single most effective way of increasing conversions and boosting revenue.
  • Ratings and reviews can only be effective as long as customers believe they are real. This is why, whether you run an ecommerce store, a consultancy or a bricks and mortar business, it’s wise to monitor your ratings and reviews so you can foster stronger, more profitable relationships with customers.

Find out more about how to eliminate fake reviews so your genuine reviews can do the talking with this eGuide: Get in shape: How to deal with fake reviews

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

What's the difference between digital marketing and traditional marketing, and why does it matter? The answers may surprise you.

Julie Cave
Julie Cave 14 July 2016
Read more
Customer Journey Mapping: A Real-Life Approach to Your Digital Marketing Strategy

Customer Journey Mapping: A Real-Life Approach to Your Digital Marketing Strategy

As financial services and insurance (FSI) companies strive to deliver the seamless multi-channel customer experience, the traditional marketing model has been radically reimagined. Innovative institutions are showing how cross-functional teams focusing on the customer journey can work to develop a single view of the customer – an approach that can bring tangible rewards. Yet research shows that large institutions still have some way to go in maximising the return on their investment in this area.

Aoife McIlraith
Aoife McIlraith 18 September 2017
Read more
Infographic - The Best Times and Days to Post to Social Media

Infographic - The Best Times and Days to Post to Social Media

With the social media landscape changing literally every single day, it's become a full-time job for social media managers to merely stay up-to-date on emerging and shifting trends and best practices. It's tedious, time-consuming, detail-oriented, and, quite frankly, a bit of a headache. But thanks to this new infographic, some guessing can be taken out of social media management.

Will Price
Will Price 21 September 2017
Read more
4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

It goes without saying that a company can't do without digital marketing in today's world.

Digital Doughnut Contributor
Digital Doughnut Contributor 5 November 2014
Read more
10 Marketing Lessons From Apple [Infographic]

10 Marketing Lessons From Apple [Infographic]

The 10-year-old kid, selling ice cold fresh lemonade on the street corner in your local neighbourhood had it right. He or she may not have realized it but the simple marketing strategy that they accidentally and innocently came up with works perfectly on the people strolling by on their daily walk.

Ellie Summers
Ellie Summers 19 September 2017
Read more