Article

Michael Nutley
Michael Nutley 11 November 2013
Categories Social Media

Choice is better than always getting your favourite pint

At Dmexco recently, Facebook’s VP advertising Andrew Bosworth began his opening keynote with a story. Like many stories, it begins with a man walking into a bar. In Bosworth’s version, the man doesn’t have to say a word before the bartender hands him his favourite drink. The man then goes over to the jukebox, where his favourite songs are all queued up ready to play. And the punchline is that this is not the man’s favourite bar in his home town, but a bar he’s never visited before, in a city he’s never visited before.

This is, or course, a familiar story of online personalisation, brought about in this case by the combination of the man’s smartphone, Facebook and its advertisers. And according to Bosworth, this is the role of brands today - to help us navigate a world of too much information.

Now it may be that beer is a really bad example to choose, but if this is the future it sounds awful. One of the joys of travelling is that you experience new things. And if you like beer, sampling the local brews is part of the fun. You might buy a really unpleasant pint, but in the rare case that happens, beer’s cheap enough to put it down to experience and order something else. Except maybe in Norway.

Of course there may be times in a foreign city when I feel lonely and in need of some reminder of home, but in that case I can ask the barman for - in Bosworth’s example - a Budweiser. I don’t need Facebook and Anheuser Busch to nanny me. In fact this whole suggested future feels like a bizarre combination of desperate parenting (“Please drink some - it’s your favourite”) and fear that, if we tried another brand, we might prefer it. But in this world that’s hyper-saturated with marketing messages, trying to lock your customers into some kind of walled (beer) garden has regularly proved not to work.

So to counter this restriction of choice masquerading as customer service, let me tell you another story. A man walks into a bar in a city he’s never visited before - in this case a real bar, in Liverpool. The bar specialises in whiskies, and offers a bewildering range of choice. The man doesn’t know what he wants, so he asks the barman for a recommendation. The barman asks him half a dozen questions about the flavours he likes, and then suggests a couple of brands, neither of which the man has come across before, but both of which he enjoys. And back home a week later he goes out and buys a bottle of each.

In this story choice is expanded, rather than reduced, but in a way that still matches Bosworth’s idea of brands helping us to make sense of a world of too much information, even if the brand in question this time is the bar rather than the drink. And the recommendation process could even be done electronically - it could be done by the bar’s app rather than the barman.

The crucial difference is that control of the transaction remains with the customer. It’s no longer tenable for a brand to concentrate solely on what it wants to sell; it has to ask what the customer wants to buy.

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

Digital Marketing Vs. Traditional Marketing: Which One Is Better?

What's the difference between digital marketing and traditional marketing, and why does it matter? The answers may surprise you.

Julie Cave
Julie Cave 14 July 2016
Read more
12 Online Editing and Proofreading Tools Content Writers Should Know About

12 Online Editing and Proofreading Tools Content Writers Should Know About

If you've got great ideas to share, but your content is riddled with errors, you could lose the trust of your readers and your credibility. Get through this editing process quickly and painlessly, by enlisting the help of some online editing and proofreading tools, so you can get your error-free content out there and read.

Gloria Kopp
Gloria Kopp 22 March 2017
Read more
4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

4 Important Digital Marketing Channels You Should Know About

It goes without saying that a company can't do without digital marketing in today's world.

Digital Doughnut Contributor
Digital Doughnut Contributor 5 November 2014
Read more
How To Create Landing Pages That Convert

How To Create Landing Pages That Convert

Effective landing pages are often standalone web pages written with one specific goal in mind. This goal is usually conversions or getting readers to take a certain action. Knowing what action you want readers to take is helpful for turning them into customers. This article will explain the six essentials of creating a landing page that converts.

Eric Gordon
Eric Gordon 20 March 2017
Read more
[Infographic] Why Email Is At The Heart Of Marketing Automation

[Infographic] Why Email Is At The Heart Of Marketing Automation

This infographic, based on Part 1 of our new report, looks at the role of email at the heart of marketing automation.

Natasha Farrell
Natasha Farrell 21 March 2017
Read more