Article

Michael Nutley
Michael Nutley 19 March 2013

Collaborate to accumulate

The nature of agency relationships, with each other as well as with clients, is changing as collaboration become vital to survival.

In the discussions at the Digital Leaders’ Briefing last month, the question of agency relationships poked through a number of times.


It’s a perennial issue, and one that seems to be broadly cyclical. A period of clients wanting to save management time by having a single lead agency managing all the others is followed, in better times, by a period where clients want to hand-pick the agency for each role and channel.


This is a generalisation, of course, as on one hand the history of the marketing department over the past 20 year has been one of outsourcing more and more to agencies, while on the other there will always be clients that subscribe the “right agency for the job” approach. Likewise there will always be individuals who prefer a single point of contact and others who enjoy playing the ringmaster.


Two things, however, are changing the nature of the discussion. The first is the growing emphasis on collaboration among agencies. The second is the hollowing out of the UK agency sector, which has seen the medium-sized independents absorbed into the big groups, leaving a small group of big multi-functional agencies and a long tail of small specialists.


This picture is further complicated by the question of what constitutes a specialist. What, for example, is the difference between a specialist search agency of 100 people, and a similar-sized search department within a bigger agency? How much is specialist status within digital marketing merely a reflection of how new the specialism is, as bigger agencies and groups wait to see how much resource to commit to the new channel?


But collaboration seems the most significant force. Speaking at the Briefing, Nicole Yershon, Director Innovative Solutions at Ogilvy Group Advertising, stressed the importance of collaboration as a source of new ideas. Her argument was that no business can be expert in everything, so having a wide network of collaborators is essential.


It’s certainly crucial for the big advertising agencies as they try to adapt to post-digital world. Having finally come to terms with the internet, they now find themselves having to rethink once more as the future looks increasingly mobile and data-driven. With their primacy under threat - as demonstrated by the recent acquisitions by WPP - drawing new expertise and approaches from small, agile specialist collaborators looks like the only viable survival strategy.


At the same time there’s still a lot of interest, particularly outside London, in developing clusters of small agencies; turning a disparate group into a community that benefits all its members and allows them to punch above their weight. The philosophy of such clusters was summed up by Jon Bains, founder of digital agency Lateral and also of a cluster in Shoreditch, as being a way to allow small agencies to compete with WPP. And with the hollowing out of the agency sector described above, the need for small specialists to collaborate in this way becomes ever more pressing.


The crucial point then becomes the business model. What makes collaboration different from simply sub-contracting out the stuff you can’t do? And if collaboration is based on ideas, how are they accounted and paid for?


These are questions that will have to be answered in the short to medium term. But beyond them there is the sense that, if and when the cycle starts to turn back in favour of the ringmasters, the balance of power may shift too. One of the things the big agencies bring to the table is access to clients. But if more clients are adopting the approach Jim Stengel lived by as global marketing officer at P&G, that he’d work with anyone as long as they were right for the brand in question, access to clients - along with size - might not command the value it once did.

Please login or register to add a comment.

Contribute Now!

Loving our articles? Do you have an insightful post that you want to shout about? Well, you've come to the right place! We are always looking for fresh Doughnuts to be a part of our community.

Popular Articles

See all
‘Complainer marketing’ – should we harness rage to promote brands?

‘Complainer marketing’ – should we harness rage to promote brands?

As marketers, we're always looking to get the best results for our clients. But should we highjack the emotions of their customers to do so? No, as I explain in this post, you're better than that.

Tom Chapman
Tom Chapman 18 July 2018
Read more
7 reasons why social media marketing is important for your business

7 reasons why social media marketing is important for your business

Social media is quickly becoming one of the most important aspects of digital marketing, which provides incredible benefits that help reach millions of customers worldwide. And if you are not applying this profitable...

Sharron Nelson
Sharron Nelson 6 February 2018
Read more
8 Digital Marketing Trends to Watch in 2023

8 Digital Marketing Trends to Watch in 2023

The internet has conditioned customers to demand instant gratification, and that’s only set to continue. In 2023, customers will expect a response time of just hours. No more sending an email and waiting days for a...

Azeem Adam
Azeem Adam 3 May 2022
Read more
The Impact of New Technology on Marketing

The Impact of New Technology on Marketing

Technology has impacted every part of our lives. From household chores to business disciplines and etiquette, there's a gadget or app for it. Marketing has changed dramatically over the years, but what is the...

Alex Lysak
Alex Lysak 22 September 2020
Read more
Deep Link vs. Universal Link: Which One is Better?

Deep Link vs. Universal Link: Which One is Better?

Are universal link and deep link the same thing? There are some big differences, let's understand them.

Stefano Pisoni
Stefano Pisoni 17 March 2020
Read more